Undervalued Spotlight #196

us 196 love diary 36Love Diary #36, Charlton Comics, January 1965

This is a bit of a coup for the Undervalued Spotlight. I believe I’ve found a yet undiscovered prototype. I’m not sure you could even call it a prototype, to me it looks more like a rip off and the perpetrators are no other than Stan Lee and Jack Kirby.

Surfing culture was all the rage in the mid 1960s; Pontiac Woodies were the vehicle of choice and the Beach Boys were getting woodies singing about California Girls. Surfing was everywhere in pop culture; Beach Blanket Bingo was everyone’s favorite movie, the surf was most definitely up.

Comics, always on the leading edge of popular culture, were working in the beach and surfing into their storylines. Charlton Comics was ahead of the pack with titles like Summer Love, Love Diary, Romantic Secrets and Teen Age Love all featuring Surfing covers.

I was leafing through some old Charltons last week when I happened upon an obscure little 7 page story draw by Charlton great Dick Giordano. No credit is given for scripts but my suspicions are that it was Joe Gill. This was around the time Joe Gill was writing more and more space based material for Strange Suspense Stories and just before Captain Atom came back to the title.

The 7 page story  titled “The Strange Surfer” is the last story in Love Diary #36 and for the reasons mentioned above I’m certain Joe Gill Wrote it.

us 196 silver surfer
OK so Kirby tossed the hair and the loin cloth but everything else looks right on.

The story tells of a mysterious surfer who effortlessly rides the waves, people watching swear he isn’t even toughing the water. Young Sally falls for this mysterious surfer but is rejected by him. He secretly tells her “I’m not of this world” and later “can’t you see my skin is not like yours, mine is silver!” Love is blind they say and Sally argues that none of that mattered. She loved him and she hoped that would be enough for him.

us 196 girl surfing
Sally wanting to join her surfer in the heavens

Gill disguised the story as a Civil Rights statement, it doesn’t matter where you come from or what color your skin is as long as you love each other.

Anyway this ‘Silver Surfer” story was a great little story and one I’ll bet Stan Lee read.

I dug into this a bit and found out that Joe Gill and Stan Lee knew each other. Joe was 3 years older that Stan but they had met in New York City in 1941 just before America entered the war. They compared notes and ran ideas by each other all the time. This relationship continued throughout their careers.

Oddly enough about a year later (March 1966) Stan Lee published Fantastic Four #48 introducing the Silver Surfer. Sure Stan’s is more polished but it was Joe Gill that came up with the concept and the Silver Surfer, that space faring silver guy on a surf board 1st appeared in Charlton Comics, in Love Diary #36 to be precise.

Start digging gang.

The 43rd edition of the Overstreet Comic Book Price Guide shows $15/$22/$28 as the 8.0/9.0/9.2 price split.

Strengths that make this comic book a good long-term investment are:

  • 1st a silver surfer
  • As yet undiscovered prototype
  • Way too cheap considering

Walter Durajlija
Walter Durajlija

Walter Durajlija is an Overstreet Advisor and Shuster Award winner. He owns Big B Comics in Hamilton Ontario.

Articles: 1712


  1. That is very interesting indeed.Jack Kirby created the Romance genre.It is an interesting premise.The dialogue certainly makes you wonder.Great spotting Walter!It’s amazing some of the interesting storylines that turn up in the Romance books of the Golden and Silver Age.

  2. This is a sweet pick and is the kind of discovery that I dig. Anyone can Google the first appearance of a character set to appear in an upcoming movie and call it “undervalued” but it takes insight to connect the dots. A great idea for collectors and people who have an appreciation for history… Definitely on my radar now ^_^

  3. Just because there are some similarities, it doesn’t mean we can trace this concept as the spark of an idea for what would become the Silver Surfer we all know. I can’t say for sure whether it’s a proto or not but don’t we need some kind of way to connect what is in the story to what appears in FF 48? Don’t we need more than this to declare it a proto?

  4. So… you mean I shouldn’t have bought up all those copies off eBay? Umm… uh… oh.

  5. i was ready to go to ebay right this second…DAMN! great article! LOL

    btw, how about an OVERVALUED spotlight? i find it hard to believe that in 20+ years anyone is going to care that rocket raccoon 1st appeared in Hulk #271…and it wont be selling for the current cost.

Comments are closed.