Undervalued Spotlight #117

Flash Comics #1, DC Comics, January 1940

This week’s post brings another first to the Undervalued Spotlight. This is the first time I’ve featured the same character in back to back posts, granted there are 70 years separating the two books!

Flash is the last of the major early DC heroes yet to break out of the comic book niche and into the main stream pop culture. Superman and Batman did it decades ago as did Wonder Woman while Green Lantern did it just recently. The Spectre has never done it and I don’t expect him to in the near future anyway. Of the major early DC heroes its the Flash that has yet to be “discovered”.

Remember that the Flash is actually the third major DC character, after Superman (June 1938) and Batman (May 1939) comes Flash (January 1940). Flash predates The Spectre by one month (More Fun #52, February 1940) and the Green Lantern by 6 months (All American #16, July 1940). The street date for Flash Comics #1 was late 1939!

So much of the DC Universe’s history centers on the Flash. It was Flash’s revival in Showcase #4 (October, 1956) that is seen as the birth of the Silver Age of comics. It was Flash’s death that was a pivotal moment in the DC Universe altering Crisis on Infinite Earths (April 1985 to March 1986) and it was the Flash title Flashpoint (May – September 2011) that ended the old DC Universe and ushered in DC’s New 52.

For all his significance in the history of DC Comics the character has never really made it out of the realm of comics in any significant and lasting way. This of course does not mean that the Flash character will not one day soon reap the rewards of wider pop culture acceptance. DC Comics has a lot invested in the Flash character and I’m sure they have plans in the works, aspiring to at least Green Lantern and Wonder Woman levels of exposure outside the insulated realm of comicdom.

Jay Garrick was the original 1940s Flash though Barry Allen and Wally West are the alter egos most fans associate with Flash. There is no changing the fact the Jay Garrick was 1st and in the 1940s he was huge. Garrick’s Flash appeared in Flash Comics, All-Flash Quarterly, Comic Cavalcade and was a founding member of the Justice Societry of America the superhero team whose adventures ran in All Star Comics. Not a bad resume. 

Flash Comics #1 doesn’t stop delivering with the introduction of the Flash, the book also introduces the Hawkman, a DC stalwart for the past 70 years. The issue also introduces Shiera Sanders the soon to be 1st female superhero Hawkgirl and Johnny Thunder (he of the number sevens).

The first 15 page story titled “The Flash” was written by Gardner F. Fox with art by Harry Lampert. The initail story has the Flash facing the Faultless Four, a group of brilliant but deadly scientists after coveted “the atomic bombarder”.

$450,000Flash Comics #1 is already a very valuable comic, it ranks 8th in value in this year’s 41st edition of the Overstreet Price Guide and the CGC 9.6 Mile High copy sold for $450,000 in 2010. Mile High pedigree aside the book has been underperforming on the market. Within the last 27 months a CGC 4.0 and a CGC 5.0 have both sold for under the Overstreet Guide value.

There are only 22 universally CGC graded copies (unrestored) of Flash Comics #1. Of the 7 comic books valued higher in the price guide only 1, the All American #16 is scarcer graded (17 CGC graded). Compare this to the 28 Detective Comics #27s, the 34 Action Comics #1s and the 69 Batman #1s and you get the sense of just how tough this book is to source.

Comparing the $400,000 guide value given to All American #16 I’d say the Flash has some catching up to do (get it). This book should be in the $250k plus range, easy!

The 41st edition of the Overstreet Price Guide shows $60,000/$107,500/$155,000 as the splits at the 8.0/9.0/9.2 grades.

Strengths that make this comic book a good long-term investment are:

  • Very scarce comic
  • 1st appearance of the Flash
  • 1st appearance of the Hawkman
  • 3rd major DC hero introduced after Supeerman and Batman
Walter Durajlija
Walter Durajlija

Walter Durajlija is an Overstreet Advisor and Shuster Award winner. He owns Big B Comics in Hamilton Ontario.

Articles: 1800
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
12 years ago

I think this is a great pick… A few years ago, this trailer was made but nothing ever came of it. From what I understand it was a legit, but who knows:


Either way, WB has been thinking about it and it’s just a matter of time before a Flash film is made. I suspect it will influence all key Flash books in the same way that the GL movie has boosted #76.

Flash #1 is way out of my reach and so is a decent copy of Showcase #4. So, I’m on the look out for a Flash #105 while it’s still relatively attainable.

Hollywood aside, I’ve always liked the Flash… more then GL. Flash is succeeds where the whiny Quicksilver fails. There are on going debates about how the Flash is actually more powerful than even Superman… but that’s another posting.

A Hawkman movie would also be very cool but unlikely in the near term. Warner/DC need a real hit, other than Batman, to help push the other characters forward…

12 years ago

A Wonder Woman movie would be good fun but don’t forget there was a Flash TV series a while back, albeit not a good one, and Kid Flash featured quite prominently in Smallville, so the Flash is not completely behind Supes and Batman. There’s also Aquaman, who might take off while Geoff Johns is making him appeal in the New 52, and Green Arrow, who’s already scheduled for a new TV series. Then again, the GL movie raised GL #76, but after the film flopped, GL #76 seems to have gone down too – a 4.5 went for $132 on eBay over the weekend, which is half what it was going for before the movie…

12 years ago
Reply to  SREW

I’ve always like GL#76. Mainly because of Neal Adams… I think it represents some of his best work. I think there’s potential for a better movie down the road but yeah, GL just didn’t hit it’s mark.

I really don’t know what’s happening at WB. Marvel is hitting them out of the park with their properties but DC seems to be struggling… even with Superman.

Anthony Falcone
12 years ago
Reply to  Charlie

However, DC is crushing Marvel with animated series and straight to DVD animated movies. Marvel is only just starting to catch up on that front.