Undervalued Spotlight #300

cerebus 1Cerebus the Aardvark, Aardvark-Vanaheim, December 1977

The 300th Undervalued Spotlight!

I thought this one through a bit and have decided to break with the tradition of picking a 300th issue (as I did with Spotlight #100 and Spotlight #200).

This week’s Undervalued Spotlight shines on Cerebus #1. The celebrated Cerebus run ends on issue #300 making it the fitting connection for this anniversary post.

I’d like to have a little fun before I laud the merits of my pick by recapping the first 300 spotlights. We’d be nowhere near #300 if it was all on me so I really have to thank all the Guest spotlight writers who have helped get us here, I’ll call out Mike Huddleston because he has been the most prolific Guest writer and I’ll not list everyone else only for fear of leaving somebody off the list. Many of our best picks have been posted by Guest writers so please keep them coming.

The Undervalued Spotlight is intended to be a fun and all inclusive exercise that covers comics regardless of era, genre or value. So far we’re done a pretty good job of not pigeon holing ourselves.

Of our first 300 Spotlights:

  • 132 have been Marvel, 73 DC and thanks to my love of Romance titles 13 Charltons
  • 67 have been from the Golden Age of 1954 or older while 60 have been from the Modern era of 1980 or newer
  • 33 were published in January making it the most “Undervalued” month
  • 5 have been Canadian Whites
  • 4 have been Magazine format
  • 13 entries (14 if you include Annuals) were Amazing Spider-Man issues making it the most “Undervalued” title

As I mentioned above Cerebus ran a celebrated 300 issues and while digging up more info I found out that DC’s John Constantine Hellblazer also ended on issue #300 while Robert Kirkman has stated that he has already planned the ending of Walking Dead and that the series will end with issue #300!

As for the Undervalued Spotlight, it has now set its sights on #301.

Enough preamble, let’s get to this week’s pick Cerebus #1.

It’s amazing the accolades Dave Sim’s Cerebus run has received. Alan Moore has called it staggering, Bill Sienkiewicz has called it one of the greatest accomplishments in comics, and Bill Willingham of Fables fame calls it one of the top 5 most important works ever in comics, while Kevin Eastman of TMNT believes we should all read it at least once.

The more I read up on Cerebus and Dave Sim the more I realized this book delivers large on two fronts. First Cerebus is a relatively scarce first issue to a massive work that is seen as a standard few hope to achieve, many view it as a great work of fiction worthy of study. Second Cerebus represents a monumental achievement in self publishing, one referenced by many as a catalyst for industry wide change and for a flowering of creative independent output.

Dave Sim was 21 when he started working on Cerebus up until then he worked for Harry Kremer at Kitchener’s Now and Then comic shop. I believe Dave wrote for the store’s Now and Then Times. Harry Kremer’s Now and Then comic shop was one of the first in Canada opening in 1971; the Joe Shuster Award for retailing bears Harry Kremer’s name.

I remember my partner and I buying Dave Sim’s rat chewed copy of Batman #1 through Harry Kremer. It must have been late 1980s and I remember how dumb and out of place the book looked beside our high end $40 Silver and Bronze Age books on our wall at comic cons. Eventually Harley Yee put us out of our misery by buying it off of us at cost and throwing us a few extra Bronze Age Spidey’s for our efforts (rookies).

I’ve actually tried to get Dave Sim to come in to do a signing at the Big B Hamilton shop but he said he needed to collect a few thousand more signatures supporting the fact that he does not hate women before he can appear in public. But I digress…

Cerebus #1 begins as a parody of Sword and Sorcery comics but the title eventually evolves into a very serious and ambitious platform for Dave Sim’s views. There’s too much weight to Cerebus for any synopsis by me to do it justice here, please jump on the net and find out for yourself.

So while we should be thankful for this epic that is Cerebus #1-300 perhaps we’re more indebted for the inspiration Cerebus gave to others, Jeff Smith (Bone) and Terry Moore (Strangers in Paradise) among many others owe the success of Cerebus much.

I think owning a nice tight 8.0 would be perfect for this book; recently a CGC 7.5 sold for $955 while an 8.5 fetched $1055.

If you are picking a raw one up at a shop or at a con please note that there are counterfeits. The best way to tell is this; the real copy has the inside cover as dull and flat feel while the fake one has a glossy cover on the outside and the inside. I read too that the real copy has silver staples and the fake one bronze staples but these are easy enough to change so go with the gloss. There are a couple of good posts online on the differences so take a bit of time and educate yourself.

The 45th Overstreet price breaks for this book is $712/$1606/$2500 in the 8.0/9.0/9.2 grade splits.

Strengths that make this comic a good long term investment are:

  • First appearance Cerebus
  • Tiny 2000 print run ensures scarcity
  • Launches epic 300 issue run that is viewed as one of the major achievements in comics
  • Celebrated as an independent publishing success that had great influence on many major creators that followed

Walter Durajlija
Walter Durajlija

Walter Durajlija is an Overstreet Advisor and Shuster Award winner. He owns Big B Comics in Hamilton Ontario.

Articles: 1801
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
mel taylor
mel taylor
7 years ago

Well, Walt, I guess you’ve got a long wait before that Sim signing. The petition has been up for a few years now and has only managed to amass 985 signatures to date. Pretty poor turnout for a guy who once had upwards of 30,000 fans. You also have to remember that many copies of Cerebus were bought by Harry Kremer to help support Dave. When Now and Then closed, there were hundreds, if not thousands, of leftover copies in stock, most of which ended up in the landfill. A sorry fate for what was once a great book and a great inspiration. to independent creators.

Eric K
Eric K
7 years ago

Another great pick, Walt. Many thanks to you and all Spotlight authors for continuing to entertain and inform, and maybe even help us make a few dollars along the way! Cheers to #300.

Mike Huddleston
7 years ago

Congrats on #300 Walt – keep going you may post a Wayne Gretzky like number that will be impossible to match.

mel taylor
mel taylor
7 years ago

Such a slouch! I forgot to say congratulations so lost in reverie I got. This post is one I have always looked to along with Mike’s Arcs and Runs and Ivan’s Whites Tsunami. I’m proud to have contributed to this baby. Take a bow brother.

mel taylor
mel taylor
7 years ago

I should also point out that Dave has unburdened himself of thousands of back issues of Cerebus by giving them to the Kitchener Comic Warehouse for Wes to hand out free in the warehouse and at conventions. However, I’m pretty certain you won’t be able to walk in and pick up a free copy of the first issue.

Charlie Kim
7 years ago

I think we can officially refer to this as the CBD300 and shop it around to the investment banks as the new hot mutual fund. Not quite the Vanguard 500 but getting there. Congrats Walt!