Which Weapon Would I Choose

This Halloween I went to a party dressed as Captain America.  I bought the movie style shield for my costume.  I also bought an army helmet and painted it blue with a big “A” on it.  While I was at the party, I strapped my shield to my back.  I had people punch my shield four times during the party.  What does this have to do with my column this week, besides people are jerks?  It got me thinking about comic book weapons and which one would I take into a fight.

Lots of Super Heroes have weapons.  It is the tool of the trade.  Many of these weapons are specific to an individual hero.  The weapons are iconic themselves.  If you mention web shooters, batarangs, Mjolnir, adamantium claws, kinetic energy charged playing cards, golden lasso, power ring, trident, billy club or shield, the hero who weilds these items instantly come to mind.

On a previous 52Q, the question was asked, what is the best weapon in comics?  At that time I answered Wolverine’s claws.  I still think that Wolverine’s claws are the best weapons in comics.  But my question today is which weapon would I take into a fight.  And it wouldn’t be Wolverine’s claws.  Why you ask?  Well that answer is simple, you gotta put the claws inside your body.  I’m not willing to go that far.

We all know the procedure Logan had to endure to have adamantium bonded to his skeleton.  I know right now I couldn’t endure that kind of pain (and I have a high tolerance for pain after my accident as a kid and that I use kratom for chronic pain ever since).  Just the thought of having molten adamantium (depending on the origin story) injected into my bones, with little tiny drill bits, just doesn’t sit well with me.  Sure I love the idea of being able to pop claws, but there is no way I would endure the procedure to have claws.  So claws are officially off the list.

After thinking about all the weapons that are currently available to super heroes, I have decided the weapon I would choose to take into a fight is… (dramatic pause for effect)… CAPTAIN AMERICA’S SHIELD.

Captain America’s shield is a mixture of Vibranium and steel (in some continuities Adamantium is also added).  It’s current discus shape was introduced in Captain America Comics in 1941.  In some continuities it was presented to Captain America by Franklin D. Roosevelt.  The shield was created by Dr. Myron MacLain, who fell asleep during the creation process and was unable to recreate the production of the original shield.

Captain America’s shield is virtually indestructible, although it has been destroyed several times.  Each time it has been destroyed, it has been repaired, usually through cosmic/magical ways.

Captain America’s shield is a defensive and offensive weapon.  That is one of the reasons I would choose it as a weapon.  I like the idea that I could use it primarily as a defensive weapon.  If I was in a fight, I could protect myself.  But don’t get me wrong.  The way Cap weilds the shield it is a formidable offensive weapon.

Cap’s shield, when thrown, is able to bounce of multiple objects, hit multiple targets and return back to Cap’s waiting hands.  I think it is impossible to understand the physics behind it (it may not be real…) but it is one of the coolest parts about the actions scenes in a Captain America book.  If I was in a fight, I would be throwing that shield all the time.  Bouncing off walls, taking out Aim troopers or Hydra agents.  Man that would be cool.

Another reason I would use Captain America’s shield is it is a target.  I read this in a comic once.  Cap’s shield is this large target and the enemy can’t help but focus on it.  Whether they are shooting at it, punching at it, or doing whatever towards it, the enemy aim at the shield rather than the person holding it.  That is a huge benefit.  You can hide behind the shield.  The enemy focuses on it.  You will be safer just having the shield with you.

While I was at my Halloween party on the weekend, that point was proven.  I had four people try to punch the shield (all in good fun).  If I didn’t have the shield I would’ve been left alone… but my costume just wouldn’t look the same.

Captain America’s shield is also a symbol, and a patriotic one.  I am a very patriotic Canadian.  I love Canada.  But Captain America’s shield is a beautiful piece of work.  It looks amazing.  I would be proud to carry that shield if I was going into a fight.  Symbols are just as important in fight, as actual fighting skill (why do you think Batman dresses the way he does?).

I guess the weapon a hero uses tells a lot about that person.  If you carry a bunch of knives, you know the confrontation is going to end up quite messy.  If your hero carries a gun, the final resolution to the conflict is going to be lethal.  If your hero carries wrist gauntlets that shoot out a web fluid, it’s non-lethal, just sticky.  Their weapon also determines how they fight.  Looking at my choice of weapon, defence is my first battle tactic.

How about you, what comic book weapon would you take into a fight?  And if you pick the Infinity Gauntlet, you need to remember even Thanos was defeated while he had the Infinity Gauntlet, so you need to choose wisely.

Ed Campbell
Ed Campbell

Ed Campbell is a collector of comics and action figures, primarily G.I. Joe. He is also a Cosplayer with Thor and Captain America as just a few of the characters in his arsenal. When not fulfilling his Comic Book Daily duties, he's "working for a living", volunteering his time for his local Fall Fair, and spending as much time with his family as possible. Use the links below to get in contact with him.

Articles: 256
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Daniel Champion
Daniel Champion
12 years ago


Chris Howard
12 years ago

Have you tried the Cap game that came out with the film? It’s kind of an Arkham clone with shield instead of batarangs, and more linear, but if the idea of tossing that shield appeals, you’ll have fun. I really liked the first time I tossed it overhand at a Hydra guy way above me.

Ed Campbell
Ed Campbell
12 years ago
Reply to  Chris Howard

I’ve been wanting to try the new Cap game. I heard on one of the game review shows (EP or something like that) that the new Cap game was something the reviewer would actually spend money on.

I’ve been waiting for it’s cost to come down. I don’t mind spending $60 on something like Arkham because I know it’s going to be good. On something I don’t know, I like to hold off a bit and buy it cheaper.

But I am interested in check it out.